Eco Meadows vs Skyridge Garden
Let us have a comparison between apple and orange. If you have a budget of about RM700,000 to RM800,000, which of these two projects would you buy?
Eco Meadows offers an exclusive landed living in a less branded location while Skyridge Garden suggests a condominium living in a glamorous island.
| Eco Meadows | Skyridge Garden | |
|---|---|---|
 |
 |
|
| Developer | Eco World | OHM Group |
| Location | Simpang Ampat | Mount Erskine |
| Property Type | Landed (2-storey terrace) | Condominium |
| Standard unit size | 2,206 sq.ft. – 2,786 sq.ft. | 1,450 sq.ft. & 2,335 sq.ft. |
| Price psf. | RM340.00 psf. onward | RM490 psf. onward |
| No. of carpark | 2 | 2 |
| Selling Price | RM743,000 onward | RM712,000 onward |
| Development land size | 30.28 acres | 7 acres (estimated) |
| Land tenure | Freehold | Freehold |
| Total units | 375 | 486 |
| Expected completion | 2018 | 2019 (Estimated) |
| Highest floor | N/A | 40 |
| 5 nearest schools |
|
|
| 5 nearest malls/eateries |
|
|
| Web popularity (Past 90 days) | 5,400 pageviews | 8,600 pageviews |
| Travelling to (off peak) |
|
|
| Key highlights (by developer) |
Architectural language of Neo-Royalty which reflects the timeless beauty of England’s most beloved royal homes where owners will be greeted by
|
(No feedback from developer) |
| More about Eco Meadows | More about Skyridge Garden |
Of course Eco Meadows!
I prefer buying a landed house more than being in a small shitty condo.
Seriously, I think that it’s unfair to compare like this.
But I will give Eco Meadows a vote as I visited their gallery last week and their concept really impressed me.
vote for eco meadows…..better landed and potential to grow area near to batu kawan…..
first point location, eco ady lose, still compare wat 😀
lol, if you want to compare location like this, Penang Island also lose to London, let’s buy EcoWorld London City Island….
Although eco meadows lose on location, but the quality of project is far more than ohm..
How good if ecoworld build skyridge..
lol u buy property no need to see location? if like that all island ppl can stay landed house in mainland d, lmao
eco bought cheapest land in maind sell highest price house, same to island bought cheapest land at paya terubong but sell highest price 1k/psf condo, eco so pro:-D
@lol
Agree with you, Eco is a bigger blood sucker than E&O. At least E&O comes slowly, say hi to you, greet you first, persuade you to lie down, give you some anesthetic, before sucking your blood gently. Whereas for Eco, straight away they will drag you into the coffin and suck you dry!
This is a rather odd comparison, between a landed vs a condo, a location on island surrounded by graveyards vs a location in mainland surrounded by pig farms. There is hardly any similarity between the 2 except for the price range of RM700k+. Bad comparison.
Who is going to stay at this lousy Simpang Ampat ? Might be those currently
staying around that area.
Island people may choose Batu Kawan due to financial.
But for Simpang Empat, I think totally out.
No Batu Kawan and Simpang Empat. Eco Meadows in Batu Kawan and EcoWorld
in Paya Terubong Penang, will definitely bankrupted this Eco World Development.
shortsighted people~ Batu kawan ,simpang ampat,mainland …lousy place ,this no good that no good …
Longsighted people~ future development and benefit.
Hehehehehhe
You people need to take a drive around that simpang ampat/batukawan area…..you may be surprised!!!!!!
Also mount erskine may be on the island, next to tanjung bungah but cmmonlah, this is mount erskine we are talking about. except for the queesnbay area, all other location on the island have been static(price-wise) since 2014
Ecoworld also usually target the rich, just loook at ecomarina
Terrible comparison.
Eco Meadows has my vote! They provide superb service and excellent hospitality.
Eco Meadows. Good concept in an up and coming area!
This is unfair to compare between Eco Meadows & Skyridge Garden. Both are different.
Anyway, Eco Meadows provide a different lifestyle concept. Once u visit their Gallery, u will notice how their service and their work. Its really impressed me after i visited.
Mainland….gone liao…only buy Penang Island…always….
Skyridge is already is in an established prime area..when the Penang Island highway start development from Gurney to Bayan Lepas, the surrounding area house prices will definitely increase.I see better and faster capital appreciation than eco.
The developer of skyridge doesnt even bother to give any feedback.. sales must be very good
@Sam
It’s idiotic to take the sales gallery as a reference.
By visiting gallery and being treated like VIP has made these people feels the project worth the money (>RM700k). I must admit Malaysian like us is easily deceived and look at thing in two dimension, they forget there is a 3rd dimension
should compare tamarind vs skyridge, then we can have apple to apple comparison for real.
@Penang
Author already said is apple to orange comparison mah
Neither would I buy. There are better buys for landed on mainland, and better buys for condos on island. Both are not worth the money. My opinion.
@
@CB
Well, I would say it is definitely a wise indicator in the decision making process. Also on the basis of quality, you clearly are unfamiliar with the other EcoWorld Projects (Semenyih,Sanctuary,Botanic,etc). Speaking of three dimensions, maybe you should do a little study/research before you speak. You know what they say about empty vessels right.. 😉
can sense a lot of Ecoworld person here trying to get sales
im working in skyridge, i feel that we have a good product. But would buy a samsung (us) if you can afford an iphone(Ecoworld)? yeah i guess so hahaha cheapskates
sorry to say… never heard of ohm developer before.. not good i guess?
@Bananasinpyjamas
ONLY one dimension need to focus is that The Margarine is situated along the
path of Tsunami or “Tsunami Bay”.
How you define lose?
For you prefer in the heavily packed island, but mainland people sure go for mainland.
Haha. Yeah. I see location and go for mainland.
Because eco forseen the price will go up la dude. That is what investment about.
Sorry to say that I’m not eco salesman. Just I prefer mainland.
Mainland Property :
Invest : Oversupply, PLENTY of vacant houses for sales, poor subsale market.
Own Stay : OK, but depends on the location to town.
Penang Property :
Invest : Depends on location, SG Ara, Bayan Baru Oversupply, Georgetown not enough supply, Tanjung Tokong moderate supply
Own Stay : As long as you’re staying in Island, why not? The proudest word from someone from mainland is “I have a property in ISLAND”
you prefer mainland because your budget is restricted within mainland
@Judge
Judge from Island. Bias and poor knowledge comparison. ha ha ha .
I think this Eco Meadows is too expensive. If anyone were to decide to move to mainland, he could get a double storey terrace house in Batu Kawan anytime for less than RM300k, sub-sale market. For RM700k, he can already get a very big semi-d there. Of course, this is for someone who thinks the size of the house is important.
For me, a 1500sf condo is good enough, I emphasize more on lifestyle, than the size of the house. So I prefer to live in a posh area on island. I want sea view in a cosmopolitan neighbourhood. I said seaview ar, but not graveyard view like those condos in Mount Erskine ar!
Are you sure properties in Georgetown not enough supply? Please visit Macallum or upcoming Sandilands.
Budget restricted within mainland? Dont simply bomb la. Islander got 500k to live in a cage and mainlander got 500k to live in a landed house. Whats the problem with budget?
U say u want lifestyle, but u criticizing others lifestyle in Eco Meadows.
Your lifestyle with seaview doesn’t mean that is lifestyle for others.
Again, u ask others to buy properties in Bt. Kawan and compare the price and size. That is not lifestyle.
@Liu
What do you get from this temporary sea view ?
Look at all the empty white elephants in mainland, condo and landed houses. People busy spending their money to buy houses with no demand. Even years after O.C and still not occupied, property agents stamping their house like Rumah-Lelong. And yet, what is the real intention of buying mainland properties?
Years ago, (Not to mention which developer) has launched Several condominium projects at once, offering DIBS. Until today, people are disposing that property on top of RM20,000 difference from their purchase price, people dont even bother to buy and some even “Sell at Cost” to avoid any burden. Where is the demand?
And now, batu kawan has 10k new houses from government coming up (Even government couldn’t dispose these houses after So-So-So-SO many roadshows and still going-on)
Is this a City of Future as they imagine?
Or a City of White Elephants on that piece of Slump with no Demand / Market at all?
@Island
Which temporary sea view? Temporary or not I don’t know lah, but for sure the graveyards have been there for hundreds of years, and another hundreds of years to come.
this man hits the nail of every man that’s dreaming of investing in Mainland really really hard on their head
@Judge
The proudest thing to say is i hv landed property in kl, who care whether island or mainland
If I were to live in a landed property it will definitely in Butterworth. No Simpang
Ampat or Batu Kawan for that matter. It’s just plain simple as ABC …………
A Mercedes will always be a Mercedes (Ecoworld) and same goes to a Proton will always be a Proton (OHM) no matter what we say or do.
Smart people will understand.
We are comparing location and not vehicles.
@Cardevect
Ecoworld = Mercedes? Haha…..I think it’s more like Mercedes Showroom but selling Protons at the price of Mercedes. Very impressive showroom, but location of properties are in low class Paya Terubong and Simpang Empat!!!!!!
At least OHM is not trying too hard to look like a Mercedes! It sells korean cars at korean price. Fair. Not that I’d buy Skyrridge Garden though.
I like your comment Cardevect…. makes a lot of sense… :
but BMW better than mercedes
@CK
Sure you do because two persons wearing the same “sarong”.
@Smart…. Chills la dude…. I just like the comments, that’s all. Whats wrong with you? I would prefer you shoot with data Instead of degrading yourself here with silly comments… You sure are funny…. A mercedes assembled in Thailand is still a Mercedes isnt it? You will still have to pay a premium to get one because its still a Mercedes… Got it?
When commodities were expensive, EcoWorld said price have to go up 10-15%. Today, the price of commodities related to building materials (mainly steel & copper) are at 20-year lows. Is EcoWorld giving any discounts ah?
@candy
“At least OHM is not trying too hard to look like a Mercedes! It sells korean cars at korean price. Fair. Not that I’d buy Skyrridge Garden though.”
100% agree with you,
OHM is selling Skyridge Garden in a reasonable market price.